If you’re preparing for a roof replacement in Washington, Missouri — or nearby towns like Chesterfield, Eureka, and Pacific — choosing the right shingle matters. Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material for homeowners in the Midwest, but with so many brands, styles, and grades available, how do you know which one is right?
At RC Roofing, we believe the decision starts with a detailed asphalt shingle comparison. From budget and durability to appearance and performance, not all shingles are created equal. In this guide, we’ll help you understand your options so you can make a smart investment for your home and your future.
Why Asphalt Shingles Are a Top Choice in Missouri
Asphalt shingles are cost-effective, versatile, and ideal for Missouri’s four-season climate. Whether you’re facing summer heat in Town & Country or winter snow in Wildwood, they provide reliable protection.
Here’s why so many of our clients in Washington, Frontenac, and Union prefer asphalt:
- Affordable compared to metal or slate
- Available in multiple styles and colors
- Easy to install and replace
- Backed by long-term warranties
- Durable enough to handle hail, wind, and rain
But before you settle on the first product you see, take time for an asphalt shingle comparison — it could save you thousands in future repairs or premature replacement.
Types of Asphalt Shingles
A proper asphalt shingle comparison starts by understanding the three core types:
1. 3-Tab Shingles
Recognized by their flat, even appearance, these are the most basic option.
- Pros: Budget-friendly, lightweight, easy to install
- Cons: Shorter lifespan (12–20 years), more susceptible to wind damage
These are best for temporary homes or rental properties in areas like Union or Pacific.
2. Architectural Shingles
Also called dimensional shingles, these are the most commonly used for residential roofing across Chesterfield and Eureka.
- Pros: 25–30 year lifespan, layered appearance, improved wind and weather resistance
- Cons: Slightly more expensive, heavier
This type is ideal for long-term homeowners seeking style and durability.
3. Luxury Shingles
Designed to mimic natural materials like slate or cedar shake, luxury shingles are the premium choice in a detailed asphalt shingle comparison.
- Pros: Best curb appeal, longest lifespan (up to 50 years), top-tier impact resistance
- Cons: Highest price point, heavier installation
Homeowners in Frontenac and Town & Country often choose these for estate homes and historic renovations.
Asphalt Shingle Comparison: Performance Factors
When you’re comparing asphalt shingles, don’t just focus on color or price. Performance is key. These are the areas to pay close attention to:
1. Wind Resistance
Missouri homes — especially those in open or storm-prone areas — need shingles rated for 110–130 mph wind resistance. Premium brands even offer upgrades to 150 mph.
An asphalt shingle comparison will help you find the balance between strength and price for your neighborhood.
2. Impact Rating
If you live in hail-prone areas like Eureka or Augusta, go for Class 4 impact-rated shingles. They resist damage from hail and may earn you discounts on homeowner’s insurance.
3. Algae Resistance
Look for shingles that include algae-blocking granules to prevent black streaks and moss growth, especially important in humid regions like Wildwood and Chesterfield.
4. Fire Rating
Most modern shingles carry a Class A fire rating — the highest possible. Always confirm this during your asphalt shingle comparison to stay code-compliant.
5. Warranty Terms
Warranties vary from 20 years to lifetime coverage. Some include labor and wind guarantees, while others are limited to material defects only. Ask your roofer for help comparing what’s covered — and what’s not.
Top Asphalt Shingle Brands for Missouri Homes
We’ve installed thousands of roofs across Missouri and here’s how leading brands stack up in a real-world asphalt shingle comparison:
GAF (Timberline Series)
- Strong performance
- Wide range of colors
- Lifetime limited warranty
- Popular in Chesterfield and Washington
Owens Corning (Duration Series)
- SureNail strip for consistent installation
- Excellent wind resistance
- Algae and stain protection
- Great for Eureka and Union homeowners
CertainTeed (Landmark and Landmark Pro)
- Thick, high-end feel
- Class 4 impact resistance options
- Stunning designer lines
- Favored in Town & Country and Frontenac
Malarkey (Legacy and Vista)
- Eco-friendly rubberized asphalt
- Exceptional flexibility and impact resistance
- Class 3 and Class 4 ratings standard
- Perfect for homes in wind and storm zones
Each brand has pros and cons, which is why an asphalt shingle comparison guided by your roofer is essential.
Visual Appeal and Home Style Compatibility
Asphalt shingles come in various shades, textures, and patterns to match any architectural style.
- Traditional Ranch: 3-tab or modest architectural shingles in earth tones
- Craftsman or Colonial: Dimensional architectural shingles with clean edges
- Estate or Historic Homes: Designer shingles that mimic slate or shake
We help clients from Wildwood to Frontenac select shingles that enhance curb appeal while respecting local architectural trends.
Cost Comparison of Asphalt Shingles
Let’s break down pricing to help with your asphalt shingle comparison:
- 3-Tab Shingles: $3.50 – $4.50/sq ft installed
- Architectural Shingles: $4.75 – $6.75/sq ft
- Luxury Shingles: $7.00 – $10.50+/sq ft
A 2,000-square-foot roof replacement (about 20 squares) would cost:
- 3-Tab: $7,000 – $9,000
- Architectural: $9,500 – $13,500
- Luxury: $14,000 – $20,000+
Labor, roof pitch, old layer removal, and ventilation updates will impact final pricing — all factors your roofer should explain during the asphalt shingle comparison.
Installation and Roofing System Compatibility
Your roof isn’t just shingles. It includes:
- Underlayment
- Ice and water shield
- Starter strips
- Ridge vents
- Drip edge flashing
A thorough asphalt shingle comparison includes how the shingle integrates into the full roofing system. RC Roofing ensures everything is installed per manufacturer specifications to qualify for warranty coverage.
Energy Efficiency and Environmental Impact
Cool roof options reflect sunlight and reduce summer cooling costs — ideal for homes in sunny areas like Chesterfield and Town & Country.
Shingles with recycled content or recyclable design (such as Malarkey’s sustainable lines) are a smart choice for eco-conscious homeowners.
How to Compare Asphalt Shingles Like a Pro
Here’s how to conduct a smart asphalt shingle comparison:
- Compare product data sheets side-by-side
- Ask about shingle weight (heavier = more durable)
- Review impact and wind ratings
- Inspect sample boards in person under daylight
- Confirm color blend and shadow lines
- Check warranty details and exclusions
RC Roofing helps walk you through this process, explaining each option in simple terms so you can choose confidently.
Why RC Roofing Is the Right Partner
We’ve served homeowners in Washington, Pacific, Eureka, and beyond with expert installation and honest guidance. When it comes to asphalt shingle comparison, we don’t just sell products — we help match the right one to your home and goals.
With RC Roofing, you get:
- Transparent quotes
- Full product and performance breakdowns
- Samples brought to your home
- Clean, code-compliant installation
- Strong workmanship warranties
We make sure your investment pays off for decades.
Final Thoughts: Choose Your Shingles Wisely
Roofing isn’t just about covering your home — it’s about protecting everything and everyone inside. A proper asphalt shingle comparison ensures you’re choosing a product that meets your expectations for cost, curb appeal, and durability.
Whether you’re in the middle of a storm restoration in Pacific or planning a long-term upgrade in Wildwood, we’re here to guide you every step of the way.
